Legal Insights on Surrogacy and Family Formation with Atty. Janna Annest

• patriotconception
• Feb 26
• 4 min read

A Journey of Legal Expertise and Personal Experience

Janna Annest’s journey into family formation law was profoundly influenced by her personal experience with adoption. In 2008, Janna and her husband adopted their daughter, exposing her to the emotional and legal complexities of the adoption process. At the time, Janna was practicing litigation, a field she found unfulfilling. Inspired by her adoption experience, she shifted her focus to family formation law, which gave her the opportunity to combine her legal expertise with a deep personal understanding of the challenges families face.

In 2010, Janna adopted her son and became both the petitioner and adoptive mother, offering her a unique dual perspective—she knew firsthand what it was like to be both the client and the lawyer. Her journey allows her to empathize deeply with her clients, which enhances her ability to navigate family formation law with sensitivity and insight.

Navigating the Intersection of Adoption and Assisted Reproduction

In this episode, Janna discusses the similarities and differences between adoption and assisted reproduction. Both adoption and surrogacy require families to undergo processes that are often emotional, vulnerable, and unpredictable. Adoption involves working with agencies or attorneys and may require a family to share personal details to match with an expectant parent. Surrogacy, on the other hand, involves working with medical professionals and other third parties, creating a public process in its own right.

Both processes involve navigating significant emotional strain, financial costs, and uncertainty. However, Janna notes that both adoption and surrogacy create tight-knit communities that can offer essential support, understanding, and guidance. These communities, which may consist of individuals who have gone through similar journeys, provide a sense of belonging for intended parents and surrogates alike.

Legal Considerations in Surrogacy: Trust and Contracts

Surrogacy is a complex legal and emotional process. Janna emphasizes that while surrogacy contracts are essential for defining the rights, responsibilities, and expectations of all parties, no contract can address every situation. The success of surrogacy arrangements often depends on non-contractual elements, such as trust and communication between intended parents and surrogates.

Washington State’s surrogacy laws provide a strong legal framework, but Janna explains that meaningful representation and counseling for both parties are crucial in addressing the inherent power imbalances in surrogacy arrangements. While intended parents often have more financial resources, surrogates may have multiple motivations, including financial, emotional, and altruistic reasons. Understanding and respecting these complexities is key to creating a successful and ethical surrogacy process.

Surrogacy Contracts: What You Need to Know

A surrogacy contract is a foundational element of any surrogacy arrangement. Janna explains that key components of a surrogacy contract include:

• Compensation: Clearly detailing the financial arrangement, including schedules and reimbursements for expenses.

• Medical Decisions: Clarifying the surrogate’s rights to make her own health decisions during the pregnancy.

• Parental Rights: Establishing the intended parents’ legal rights to the child.

• Termination Clauses: Outlining conditions under which the contract can be ended by either party.

• Dispute Resolution: Providing a framework for addressing conflicts that may arise during the process.

Understanding Surrogacy Contracts and Legal Parentage

One of the most important roles of a surrogacy contract is to establish legal parentage. Janna elaborates on how surrogacy contracts work in conjunction with pre-birth parentage orders, which legally recognize the intended parents as the parents of the child before birth. This legal safeguard ensures that parental rights are clear and avoids potential complications once the child is born.

For international surrogacy cases, pre-birth orders are particularly crucial, as some countries, like Australia, rely on these orders to ensure the intended parents are recognized as the legal parents in their home country.

Navigating International Surrogacy and Legal Frameworks

Janna also discusses the differences between domestic and international surrogacy cases. Working with international intended parents presents its own set of challenges due to varying laws in different countries. For instance, Australian intended parents require pre-birth orders to avoid a conflict of parental rights with Australian law. International cases may also involve more transactional dynamics, as surrogates and intended parents often have less direct interaction.

Janna stresses the importance of understanding the legal landscape when working with international clients, as cultural and legal differences can add additional layers of complexity to the surrogacy process.

Key Takeaways for Intended Parents and Surrogates

In conclusion, Janna provides essential advice for intended parents and surrogates:

• Trust and Relationships: The foundation of a successful surrogacy arrangement is built on mutual trust and communication. Contracts are important, but they cannot replace the need for a strong personal relationship between intended parents and surrogates.

• Awareness of Power Dynamics: Surrogates and intended parents must be mindful of power imbalances and ensure that both parties have meaningful representation and counseling to ensure fairness and transparency.

• Community Support: Whether adopting or engaging in surrogacy, intended parents and surrogates benefit from being part of a supportive community that understands their unique challenges. These communities provide invaluable resources, empathy, and emotional support throughout the process.

• co-parenting
• Fertility Friday Radio
• Infertility Podcast